Friday, March 10, 2006

Ataa Ayi

Ataa Ayi
Ataa Ayi Goes To Appeal Court(6/10/2005)
Story: Stephen Sah


Aryee Aryetey, alias Ataa Ayi, who is standing trial at the Accra Fast Track High Court for his alleged involvement in various robberies, has gone to the Court of Appeal to challenge the trial court’s decision not to strike out certain names ascribed to him by the prosecution.He has also filed an application for an order of stay of proceedings at the Fast Track High Court pending the determination of his appeal.Mr Joseph Akyeampong, counsel for the appellant in the case in which the accuse is standing trial with eight others for robbing a woman of $65,000, ¢45 million and other valuables at Taifa in Accra in 2003, filed both suits yesterday on behalf of his client. The cases will be heard on June 21, 2005.Three of the suspects are already standing trial with the appellant in connection with a robbery at Dzorwulu in which they allegedly robbed a man of ¢70 million.They are Kwabla Agbodogah, alias Rojay, Samuel Kweku Annan, alias Sammy Tugah, and Raymond Ameh, while the five others are Nana Yaw Owusu, alias Tonny, Yaw Asante Agyakum, alias Akpor, Stephen Nyarko, Frederick Lamptey Annan, alias Numue, and Nana Osei Razak.All the nine suspects have pleaded not guilty to two counts of conspiracy and robbery and are on remand.On June 6, 2005, Mr Akyeampong raised a preliminary objection to the prosecution calling the appellant by the aliases, which included “One Touch”, and prayed the court to strike them out because the appellant had never been known by those names. But the court overruled the objection and said the police, after their investigations into the matter, used those names to refer to the appellant who had responded to them anytime he had been called by them.In the notice of appeal, the appellant stated that he was dissatisfied with the Fast Track High Court ruling because the judge failed to give consideration to the fact that those names which had been stated in the charge sheet had never been borne by him, either in the present or the past.According to the appellant, the judge failed or refused to take account of the fact that in a criminal trial, the onus was on the prosecution to describe properly and identify an accused by stating whatever names it decided to use to describe him.In his application for stay of proceedings, the applicant averred that he could not be made by the prosecution and the Fast Track High Court to assume a name or names which he did not bear and hoped that the Court of Appeal would stay proceedings in the matter until the determination of his appeal.He said the outright refusal of his application without any compelling reason to do so was highly prejudicial to him and an infringement of his fundamental human right to be heard and the right to a name of choice.

Democrat newspaper

Democrat newspaper
Friday, March 10, 2006
Story: Stephen Sah

Democrat Fined ¢400m
THE Accra Fast Track High Court yesterday slammed ¢400 million damages and ¢10 million costs against the National Democrat in a defamation suit filed against the newspaper by the Defence Minister, Dr Kwame Addo-Kufuor.In its judgement, the court held that the National Democrat newspaper was published by faceless publishers because D.D.D. Publications, its publisher, only existed in name and had no registered offices anywhere in the country, contrary to the law.Story by Stephen Sah“The records before the court indicate that the National Democrat newspaper is printed in a mobile fashion from one private house to another to avoid any detection of its real source of publication,” the court said in its judgement of the suit filed by Dr Addo-Kufuor against the publisher of the newspaper and Ebenezer Josiah, a former editor, for defamation.An order for a perpetual injunction to restrain the defendants and their agents from printing and publishing any further libellous material against the plaintiff was, however, dismissed because, according to the court, it should not assume a responsibility in what journalists or the press was supposed to publish.“Our duty arises only after the publication has been made and we are called upon to determine whether it is defamatory or not. Our duty does not extend to any unknown future publication,” the court said.Dr Addo-Kufuor sued the defendants for a story written about him in the October 4-6, 2004, edition of the National Democrat. The picture of the plaintiff was also printed and placed beside the story with the following question posed under it: “Hon. Addo-Kufuor - Will he tell the truth?” and which, according to the plaintiff, portrayed him as a murderer who was involved in the serial killing of women between 1999 and 2000, a crime for which Charles Quansah was arrested, tried and convicted as one of the perpetrators.The plaintiff issued a statement vehemently denying the allegations contained in the story but the defendants refused to withdraw the story and failed to apologise to him.Instead, the newspaper continued to publish more articles, with accompanying pictures, against the plaintiff.The court held that Josiah, on November 11, 2004, purported to enter a conditional appearance for himself and on behalf of the publishers but it was deemed to have entered for himself.Following that, the court applied to have the publisher served by substituted service but all attempts to trace the publisher proved futile.Josiah told the court that he had no defence to the action since he could not prove nor justify the allegations contained in the story.Consequently, the plaintiff filed an application for interlocutory judgement against the defendants in default of defence of appearance, and on the day of judgement, Josiah sought leave of the court to adjourn to enable him to consult a lawyer to assist him to file a defence.That, he said, was because his employers had a lawyer but since he came out on his own to retract the story and apologise to Dr Addo-Kufuor, he believed the lawyers would not be interested in defending him in the case.On the basis of Josiah’s confession and admission that he could not defend the action because the publication had no basis and was unjustified, the court, on January 19, 2005, entered judgement against the defendants in plaintiff’s favour for libel and adjourned the case for the assessment of damages.The court said from what Josiah told it, at the time they published the story accusing the plaintiff of being involved in the serial killing of women, they knew very well that they were neither publishing the truth nor informing the public about the truth of the murders.Rather, it held that they were peddling calculated lies and falsehood in their newspaper, with the sole aim of destroying or damaging the enviable reputation of the plaintiff.“Is it proper and legal for a faceless person or group of persons to hide behind a non-existent statutory body like D.D.D. Publications to produce a newspaper in which a malicious campaign of vilification and untruth calculated only to destroy is relentlessly carried out, distributed and magnified through the Internet and FM radio stations to the world?,” the court asked.The court held that while no person or group of persons was to be restrained from operating a mass media and publishing what he /it thought was right or in the interest of the general public, that freedom was subject to limitations, which included the rights and freedoms of others.It said despite the fact that the plaintiff was accused of homicide, not even of one person but several women, which was a very serious offence punishable by death if found guilty, the defendants did not do anything to show that they had regretted their action.“They rather made matters worse when they continued to publish more defamatory material against the plaintiff in several subsequent editions of their newspaper, which, the plaintiff tendered in evidence during the trial,” the court stated.According to the court, those subsequent publications and the fact that the defendants knew the allegations of murder levelled against the plaintiff were baseless and without any foundation exposed the actual malice that the defendants harboured against him at the time of the publications.The court said damages awarded in defamatory actions were intended to compensate or enrich the defamed or the plaintiffs concerned for the injury to their reputation and to cool the hurt feelings and also to make defendants feel the pinch of their wrongful conduct.“While I regard myself as a champion and advocate of free speech and freedom of the press and, therefore, would always protect the press or the mass media in general against oppression of any kind, I seriously abhor irresponsible journalism, which has been the catalyst of most civil wars that we experience on our continent these days,” said Mr Justice Yaw Appau, who presided.

Thursday, March 09, 2006

Do journalists need protection and are they special people?

Are journalists special?
SEMINAR PAPER DELIVERED BY MR STEPHEN SAH, DAILY GRAPHIC, ACCRA, GHANA AT THE WOLFSON COLLEGE PRESS SEMINAR UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE (27 FEBRUARY 2006)

Permit me to begin my paper with this quotation (the thrust of my argument) from the Accra Herald of Monday October 5, 1857.
Charles Bannerman then writing in the Gold Coast said "In civilized communities, the press deservedly occupies a high position. The mass of mankind (lack) either the leisure or the capacity to form a sound opinion on most questions of the day - an opinion founded on calm reflection and thorough examination of the subject. Men's opinions therefore, where there is no press, are often mere whims and fancies, formed on very trifling knowledge of the matter. Their information is often incorrect. It is good therefore for the public that there should be a set of men who devote their time and ability to collecting and distributing general information. And it is good that these men should make it their duty to examine questions of importance, and submit their opinions, when matured, to the public. As long as these men do their duty fairly and with judgment, they ought to be supported by the public."
The above quotation points to the fact that the issue as to whether journalists should have special dispensation by the nature of their work has remained crucial for quite sometime especially when the media is considered as the fourth estate of the realm.There are those who believe that journalists are non entities and they should be placed at where they belong- they do not play any meaningful role in the development of the society. After all journalists are trouble rousers and should be blamed for the confusion within the world polity, they argue. After all, they invade the privacy of individuals. They report lots of government secrets and engage in other irresponsible practices just to sell more newspapers, or to get higher viewer ratings.There is yet another group who think that journalists already enjoy much freedom and the question should be put to rest. And this is supported by the results of a 2002 survey conducted by the American Freedom Forum's First Amendment Center in which 42 per cent of those polled thought that the press has "too much" freedom.Those who think this way further believe that journalism can be practiced by anybody who can put pen to paper and there isn't the need to train people as journalists and much more give them special privileges just for them to engender chaos in the society.This argument was bolstered recently here at Wolfson during a lunch conversation. Since we are press fellows the issue of journalism came up and one gentleman did not hesitate to remark that "Journalism is all about ethics and nothing else".I however hold a different view and am of the opinion that journalists should be specially trained and given the necessary support in the form of laws to allow for press freedom, protection of sources and immunity during war because of their role in society. Anything but this will absolutely throw journalism to the gutter. In spite of the fact that the Internet has become a medium that crosses borders instantaneously, enabling information and ideas to be disseminated in the twinkling of an eye determining whose standards and laws should apply to the speech and the speakers who use it to communicate will be one of the major challenges of the 21st century.This notwithstanding there need not be a long screed here on how journalism benefits our society. That has been well-documented. The press, for instance, helped build the American society and facilitated the independence struggle in my country Ghana. Journalists strongly fight for the vulnerable in society, freed innocent and wrongly-accused people from bad governments and laws. They have helped to unseat many corrupt governments and have told stories of war which would otherwise not have been told. A world without the journalist would be in total darkness. May I then say that journalists are the light of the world? How many of us gathered here this evening could imagine life without knowing what's happening in other parts of the world? When people are at their leisure best is it not the journalist who sweats and dreads to light the flame of the world by highlighting in eerie situations and circumstances?Should journalists not be protected during times of war, in searching for the truth and for that matter about information? Why should there be restrictions in their way?Journalists don't have to take a test or pass a series of board interviews to practice their profession. There isn't any journalist's license, nor should there be.Journalism, while a practice in objectivity, is a subjective art, there can be no test to measure such art. And, frankly, just like there are bad journalists, there are bad doctors and bad lawyers. However the bad doctors and lawyers are afforded the same shield as the good ones. Hence, journalists should enjoy the same protection as doctors, lawyers, and the like.If people who know the news cannot feel free to reveal the news, then there will be no news. Those people who know the news should feel comfortable trusting a journalist to not later reveal their identity. If not, who knows what would go on behind closed government doors?For example why should a man who has classified government information, which if not released would lead to the death of thousands of people lose his job if found to have released that information?If journalists cannot promise source anonymity, the sources will dry up and if the sources dry up, journalists will be relegated to reading well-edited and censored press releases. In situations where there is no protection for journalists the society will not be far from Hobbes' postulations of war for all against all.Asking protection for journalists should not provide us with the license to kill. No. As those who mirror our society journalists should be shown the way and to quote a proverb from Ghana "He who is charting the path does not know whether it is warped or not". And journalists like path charters will not know whether the path is warped or not so obviously there should be someone behind to point out the right path. This is where the issue of ethics becomes relevant.Lazy journalists who don't feel like working to actually confirm a story will talk to one person and say "According to unnamed sources" while eager journalists will let government officials use them to trash political opponents under the guise of "government sources tell us..." Some so-called journalists just make up stuff and attribute it to "sources."It's all about responsibility on all sides. It's up to journalists to use a measure of good sense about what they report and what they do not. It's up to journalists' superiors to make sure their employees are acting in a responsible manner.

supreme court

supreme court
Supreme Court Was Properly Constituted(7/28/2005)
Story : Stephen Sah


The Attorney General(AG)and the Chief Justice(CJ)have stated that the Supreme Court was properly constituted when it heard the appeal filed by Tsatsu Tsikata, the former Chief Executive of the Ghana National Petroleum Corporation (GNPC),in respect of his trial at the Fast Track High Court. They said by virtue of Article 157(3)of the 1992 Constitution, Mr Justice S.A.Brobbey,who was on secondment to The Gambia did not withdraw from the panel and did not become ‘functus officio’ until he delivered his opinion for inclusion in the judgement.“The court was duly constituted when it heard the appeal and there is no constitutional requirement that all the judges must sit in open court to deliver their opinions,” they said.These were contained in a statement of defence filed by the Attorney General in the suit filed against him and the Chief Justice by Tsikata at the Accra High Court seeking a declaration that the Supreme Court’s 4-1 decision of November 8, 2004 on his submission of ‘no case’ was null and void. The defendants said it was a long-standing practice of the court,particularly in view of Article 157(3) of the Constitution,to announce the judgement or decision of the court,even if all the judges who participated in the hearing were not present,provided they had made known their opinion.Tsikata is also seeking an injunction to restrain the defendants,their agents,servants and assigns from taking any step based on that purported judgement.According to the statement,the judgement of the Supreme Court on the matter was not a purported order but its valid and subsisting judgement.“The defendants say that Mr Justice Brobbey expressed his opinion on the matter before the court and it was on account of this that the decision of the court, as pronounced by the presiding justice,came to a majority 4-1, meaning the appeal failed and was dismissed,” the statement said.They stated that under Article 130(1)of the Constitution, the Supreme Court had exclusive original jurisdiction in all matters relating to the enforcement or interpretation of the Constitution.Consequently,the court should stay proceedings and refer the question on whether or not the Supreme Court was duly constituted when it heard Tsikata’s appeal to the Supreme Court for determination under Article 130 (2) of the Constitution.According to the defendants,Tsikata was not entitled to any relief as was being claimed by him.Tsikata argued,among others,that the court’s judgement was null and void because at the time that it was delivered,the Supreme Court was not properly constituted. Tsikata’s contention was that in that appeal,the Chief Justice empanelled five justices of the Supreme Court, including Mr Justice Brobbey, then on secondment to The Gambia as Chief Justice, to determine the case.“With the departure of Justice Brobbey to assume duty as Chief Justice of The Gambia, to the knowledge of the first defendant, it was incumbent on him, by virtue of Article 125(4)of the 1992 Constitution, to ensure a panel of five Justices of the Supreme Court for the hearing and determination of the appeal,” he said in his statement of claim.

grandparent

grandparent
Grandpa In Court For kidnapping
By Stephen Sah


Grandparrent’s love for their grandchildren is very great, especially when crises rock the marriages of their parents.But such love which made a grandfather to forcibly take custody of his grandchildren from their father’s relatives has landed Stephen Aboagye Boateng in trouble.He was arraigned at the Accra Circuit Court last Tuesday on charges of abetment to assault and kidnapping.He pleaded not guilty. Boateng,a driver,was granted bail in the sum of ¢50 million with a surety and asked to re-appear on August 26.Prosecuting,Deputy Superintendent of Police (DSP),Kofi Abraham, said Emmanuel Oteng Appiah and Alexander Nti,the complainants,were brothers and lived at Golf City,Michel Camp,near Tema.The accused person,he said,lived at Site 21,Community One, also in Tema and the father of Justice Aboagye Boateng, alias Dada,who lives in Accra.According to DSP Abraham,the complainants’brother,Joseph Appiah Commey was married to Doris Aboagye,the daughter of the accused,with whom they had a child called Kingsley Twumasi Appiah Commey,aged nine.He said the couple later left the country to live in New York and left the child in the custody of the complainants.In New York,he said,the couple had two other children, Emelia Appiah Commey,six,and Emmanuel Appiah Commey,two, who were brought to Ghana by their father to stay with the complainants.The prosecutor said on or before July 19,this year,the accused person received a letter from his daughter in New York instructing him to go for her children from the complainants.Consequently,DSP Abraham said,the accused instructed his son,Dada,and Kwaku and four others to go for the children by any means.He said the six persons went to the residence of the complainants and decided to take the children by force but the complainants refused resulting in their being beaten up before the children were taken away.When the accused was arrested on July 21,this year,and was granted a self-enquiry bail to report the following day with the children and those he sent to go for the children,he told the police that they had gone to Mpraeso and would be back on Sunday,July 24,2005.On July 25,the accused reported to the police that the men had not returned to Accra and that he did not know Dada’s residence in Accra to enable him to bring the children over

chief

chief
Mamponghene Loses Defamation Suit
Story:Stephen Sah

The Mamponghene, Dasebre Nana Osei Bonsu II, has lost the defamation suit he filed at the Accra Fast Track Court against Mr Ben Ephson, Editor of the Daily Dispatch, Mr Akwasi Mensah, a reporter of the newspaper and Allied News Limited, the publishers.The court awarded costs of ¢5 million to the defendants.The plaintiff was claiming ¢500 million in general and special damages for a publication in the April 9, 2003, edition of the newspaper that he received $30,000 (¢264 million) as consideration for nominating one Mrs Rosina Mensah as queen of Asante Mampong.He also sought an order of injunction to restrain the defendants, their agents, representatives, workmen and those connected with the operation and workings of the defendants from continuing their malicious publication calculated to tarnish his reputation.But the court found the publication to be true and a fair comment, especially when the office of the queen of Mampong was a matter of grave public interest.“Having found that the allegation is true, the defendants’ publication and comments made thereon is a fair comment. I am of the opinion the defendants have, on a whole, been able to establish their defence,” the court held.The story which was under the headline “Mamponghene in ¢264 million fraud” indicated that the “ Asantehene and occupant of the Golden Stool, Otumfuo Osei Tutu II, has a difficult task before him. He has before him an eight-page petition against the occupant of the Silver Stool, the Mamponghene, Nana Osei Bonsu.”According to the story, the petition, alleging injustice and fraud, had a 25-page attachment, including a note signed by the Mamponghene acknowledging receipt of $30,000, as consideration for nominating Mrs Rosina Mensah as queen of Asante Mampong.It said for the doubting Thomasses, the signed note acknowledging the receipt of $30,000 was scanned on the back page of the paper for the perusal of readers.The publication stated that the two petitioners, Obaapanin Afua Amadie and Obaapanin Afua Buor, both elders of the Botase family of the Mampong Traditional Area in their petition, stated that the Mamponghene sought the advice of his confidant, Mr Alex Boakye Osei Bonsu, as to who to nominate as the queen of Mampong.Mrs Mensah, who was working in New York, according to the story, was contacted and she expressed interest in the position and eventually invited the Mamponghene, then on a visit to New York, to the residence and that it was at a dinner in the residence that the $30,000 was collected by the Mamponghene.In a reciprocal agreement, the Mamponghene acknowledged receipt of the money and promised to make Mrs Mensah, also known as Nana Abena Nyantakyi, the next queen of Mampong.However when she came to Ghana with items for her enstoolment, somebody else had been nominated.An elated Ben Ephson described the judgement as a victory for the Ghanaian media saying that while the courts would not allow the media to be reckless, they also protected them once the right thing had been done.Meanwhile, the plaintiff had filed a notice of appeal against the court judgement, arguing that the court erred in dismissing his suit.A group calling itself the Concerned Citizens of Mampong besieged the court premises calling for the dethronement of the chief.Immediately after the judgement, some people poured talcum powder on themselves and cast aspersions on the followers of the chief.The people carried placards, one of which portrayed their chief as a “ liar and a disgrace to the Silver Stool” .The followers of the Mamaponghene nearly beat up a press photographer who attempted to take a photograph of their leader, especially when they heard that the other people wanted to remove the sandals of the chief to signal his destoolment.

lawyer

lawyer
New Lawyer Remanded Over $39,000 Deal(10/5/2004)
Story: Stephen Sah


Barely 72 hours after being enrolled as a lawyer, Kweku Sam-Amoah,was yesterday remanded by an Accra circuit court for allegedly forging documents of his employers to steal $39,000.He was among the 151 new lawyers called to the Bar last Friday.The accused, together with a clearing agent, Quansah, who is at large, were said to have forged delivery orders of Blue Funnel Ghana Limited, and collected the money from importers without entering the payments in the record books of the company.Sam-Amoah, who graduated from the Law School last Friday, has pleaded not guilty to 12 counts of forgery of documents and stealing. He will re-appear on October 8.The facts of the case as narrated by the prosecutor, were that Sam-Amoah was the release manager of Blue Funnel Ghana Limited, a division of Hull Blyth (Gh) Limited, a registered shipping company in Ghana.The company is responsible for the processing of documents for the discharge of cargo from vessels. It then allows importers to ship their cargo and pay the freight charges later, on the arrival of the cargo at their destination.Sam-Amoah was the officer who ensured that the importers paid their freight before the Release Order was issued to enable them to clear their goods.According to the prosecutor, Sam-Amoah allegedly connived with Quansah and contacted some importers whose goods had arrived to pay for the freight directly to him (Sam-Amoah) and sometimes through Quansah for the release of the goods.However, after collecting the freight charges, Sam-Amoah failed to pay them into the accounts of the company.The deal was uncovered during a recent audit at the company which revealed that 13 companies cleared their containers between 2002 and 2003, without paying the freight charges totalling $39,000.Records at the Ghana Ports and Harbours Authority indicated that Sam-Amoah endorsed all the Release Orders which included that of Bismark Agyepong Teyrich Enterprise of Accra, with number 0009847 and issued on May 22, 2003, Nayab Enterprise of Accra, with number 0008521 and issued on February 2,2003.Others were Geoka Enterprise Limited, with number 0004943 and issued on April 4, 2003, Yaa Mansah with number 0005039 and issued on April 9, 2003, Samora Enterprise Limited with number 0000856 and issued on January 1, 2003, and Primento Enterprise ( no number).The rest were Joseph Osei Ahenkorah with number 0000638, Walset Company Limited with number 0001995 and O.K.C.Enterprise with number 0003247.The accused, according to the prosecutor, admitted the offence in his caution statement after his arrest while witnesses invited by the police had all confirmed they paid for the freight

Tsikata

Tsikata
Court Orders Tsikata To Open Defence(6/29/2005)


The protracted battle waged by Mr Tsatsu Tsikata, former Chief Executive of the Ghana National Petroleum Corporation (GNPC), against being prosecuted under the law of willfully causing financial loss to the state came to an end yesterday when the Supreme Court ordered him to open his defence.The trial will now take place at the Fast Track High Court against which Tsatsu earned a significant legal victory in 2002.He is to answer charges on three counts of causing financial loss of about ¢2.3 billion to the state through a loan he, on behalf of the GNPC, guaranteed for Valley Farms, a private cocoa producing company, and another count of misapplying public property.On February 28, 2002, the Supreme Court ruled in his favour that the Fast Track High Court was unconstitutional and, therefore, could not try him. That decision set the tone for a long legal battle when the Attorney General and Minister of Justice fought and had the decision overturned by the Supreme Court.Yesterday saw the finality of that battle when the Supreme Court, by a majority decision of 6-1 dismissed the application filed by Tsikata for a review of its 4-1 decision of November 8, last year, that he should stand trial at the court and answer charges of willfully causing financial loss to the state.It held that the application for review was not an appeal and that the applicant could not make any exceptional arguments that the court’s decision ought to be reviewed.The Chief Justice, Mr Justice George Kingsley Acquah, who presided, read the majority decision and stated that the scope of the court’s review jurisdiction was not in doubt that a review was neither an appeal nor a reaction to emotions.Other members on the majority side were Ms Justice Sophia Akuffo, Mrs Justice Georgina T. Wood, Professor Justice Modibo Ocran, Mr Justice Julius Ansah and Mr Justice R. T. Aninakwa.Mr Justice William Atugubah maintained his earlier stance of dissension.Earlier, the lead counsel for Tsikata, Professor E. V. O. Dankwa, in arguing the application, tried to raise an objection that there was no case before the court, since the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Mr Osafo Sampong, had reached his retiring age.Counsel was, however, reminded of his pending application, in which he had argued that the court, in its earlier decision, overlooked certain vital issues which were in favour of his client.He said that judgement could not stand as the law of the land because the majority relied on Common Law, which was contrary to statutory provisions, saying that even those provisions relied upon were applied wrongly.Valley Farms contracted the loan from Caise Francaise de Developpement, a French aid agency, in 1991 but defaulted in the payment, compelling the GNPC, which acted as the guarantor, to pay it in 1996.When Tsikata made his maiden appearance at the Fast Track High Court in February 2002 to answer the charges, he refused to enter a plea and openly declared that the court did not have jurisdiction to try him.However, the court, presided over by Mr Justice Julius Ansah, then an Appeal Court judge with additional responsibility as a High Court judge, entered a plea of not guilty on his behalf and granted him a ¢500 million self-recognisance bail.While the case was pending at the court, Tsikata filed a writ at the Supreme Court on February 11, 2002 challenging the constitutionality of the Fast Track High Court and argued, among others, that it was not recognised by the 1992 Constitution.He subsequently filed a motion for an injunction to restrain the Attorney General from proceeding with his trial at the court.The Supreme Court, on February 28, 2002, by a decision of 5-4, declared that the Fast Track High Court was unconstitutional.Following that decision, Tsikata became temporarily a free man until the full bench was constituted, with the government appointing the late Justice Dixon Kwame Afreh to the Supreme Court. The then Chief Justice, Mr Justice E.K.Wiredu, empanelled the full bench of 11 judges to hear the review. Tsikata again challenged that decision, including the appointment of Justice Afreh, but to no avail. On May 28, 2002, the Supreme Court described that application by Tsikata as unmeritorious and dismissed it and awarded ¢5 million costs against him.The long-standing controversy surrounding the constitutionality of the Fast Track High court was resolved when the Supreme Court, on June 26, 2002, overturned its earlier decision that the Fast Track High Court was unconstitutional.That was after the then Attorney General and Minister of Justice, Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo, had filed an application for a review, in which he prayed the court to set aside its 5-4 decision.In that ruling, the full bench, by a majority decision of 6-5, reinstated the Fast Track High Court and awarded costs of ¢10 million against Tsikata.After the dust had settled, Tsikata went to stand trial at the Fast Track High Court to answer the charges levelled against him. However, on the close of the prosecution’s case, he made a submission of 'no case' and argued that the prosecution failed to link him to the charges and, therefore, he should be set free.The court dismissed his application and stated that the prosecution had proved a case for which he should be called upon to answer.Not satisfied, Tsikata appealed against that decision at the Court of Appeal but he again lost and was asked to stand trial at the Fast Track High Court.He further went to the Supreme Court to appeal against the Court of Appeal decision and it was dismissed by a 4-1 majority decision, for which reason he filed the motion for the review.The Republic, at various stages of the trial, was represented by the former Attorney General and his deputy, Nana Akufo-Addo and Ms Gloria Akuffo, the DPP, a Principal State Attorney, Mrs Gertrude Aikins, and Mr Augustines Obour, an Assistant State Attorney, while Major R.S. Agbenato (Retd) was in Tsikata’s legal team.
Story: Stephen Sah

wolfensohn

wolfensohn
Story: Stephen Sah, London

Former World Bank President, Mr James D. Wolfensohn,has urged countries in the Commonwealth to share theirexperiences in order to bridge the growing poverty gapbetween them. He said without equality stability is unlikely,especially in thedeveloping countries and therefore the onus lies onthese countries to address issues such as universal basic education,health, gender inequality and trade among themselves and with othercountries because of their enormous benefits todevelopment. Mr Wolfensohn, who is now Special Envoy to the Quartetfor the Gaza Disengagement was delivering the 9th AnnualCommonwealth Lecture at the Institute of Education ofthe University of London on Thursday. It was on thetheme "The future of the Commonwealth: A bridgebetween an emerging three speed world. He said since equality and social justice were thefocal point of the Commonwealth, which has a tremendous thrust to drawon these values. These values could be achieved by sharingexperiences, he added. According to him, if that was not done now it wouldbe difficult in the next 10 to 20 years where therewould be a huge change in the dynamics between richand poor countries. The former World Bank Presidentcalled on Commonwealth countries to createbusiness-friendly environment to encourage people toinvest which will ensure competition and more foreigndirect investment. He cited for instance that while it took less than 13days to get a business registered in the European countries, ittook more than 23 days and 48 days to do the same inAsia and developing countries. He said that by 2050 four countries namely Brazil,Russia, China and India would be among the 10 topworld best nations in terms of real Gross DomesticProduct (GDP) and the developing world’s total GDP ofabout 20 per cent was likely to double over the periodif measures were taken to address the issues raised. Currently, he said, the G8 (7) nations whichconstitute 20 percent of the world population have atotal share of 80 per cent GDP while the developingcountries have a share of 20 per cent. Mr Wolfensohn said too many of the Commonwealthcountries, especially in sub-Saharan Africa wouldcontinue to be poor while the rich would also continueto be rich. He said Africa's problem was more related toleadership and it was through accountability, goodplanning and implementation coupled with the tacklingof education, health and other issues that thecontinent would come out of its predicament. The issueof corruption, he noted, had a social and culturalroots and needed to be address from that perspectivevis-à-vis good leadership. Some of the past speakers at the lecture includeUnited Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan (2000),Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo (2005).

ghana high commissioner

ghana high commissioner
Story: Stephen Sah, Cambridge

Ghana’s High Commissioner to the United Kingdom has said the passage of the Representation of the People’s Amendment Law, (ROPAL) was a constitutional requirement to give back to Ghanaians what was taken away from them and not a mischievous attempt by the government to create confusion in the country.
“It was the government’s responsibility to do that but is left with the Electoral Commission (EC) to decide whether it can implement it at any in the next general elections or not”, the High Commissioner told the Cambridge University Ghanaian Society on Saturday.
Mr Osei was speaking as the guest when he met with the Ghanaian students on Saturday as part of Ghana’s 49th Independence Anniversary celebrations to share ideas with them on developments back home and government programmes and policies at aimed moving the country forward.
Under the theme “Ghana in the 21st Century - The way forward, the occasion provided a platform for the students to ask questions on certain policies of the government such as the ROPAL, the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative (HPIC), why the government should guarantee loan for Members of Parliament alone and not any other category of public workers among others.
According to Mr Osei the ROPAB was an amendment of a PNDC Law to give to Ghanaian what was taken away from them and it was not the intention of the government to use it to rig any elections as being claimed by a section of Ghanaians since its implementation is the responsibility of the independent EC.
Giving an overview of the events which preceded Ghana’s independence, he said, the Bond of 1844 which was signed on March 6 to enable Britain to assume legal control over the Gold Coast was significant since independence was achieved 113 years after that event.
Mr Osei paid glowing tribute to all those who championed the nationalist movement, especially the Big Six, war veterans and the people saying that although some of the leaders did not agree on issues leading to division within the United Gold Coast Convention (UGCC) they together fought a good cause for the attainment of independence for the country.
Explaining why the country adopted the HIPC initiative, he said, it was the only option to benefit from debt relief and put the country on the pedestal of development since all the monetary relief used for development projects would have gone into debt servicing.
The High Commissioner explained that since most corruption took place in public procurement the government was tackling it by enacting the Public Procurement Act and the Financial Administration Act to ensure transparency in controlling the canker saying that that it was the implementation of those laws that corruption could be controlled.
He the millennium development goals coupled with good leadership was what would propel the country into a middle income status since the country needed a leadership which would not only be accountable to the people during elections but before the laws of the land.

Accra Beat

From Cambridge with Love:

Thursday, February 02, 2006